Nieman's 3rd TD vs SEU
45
Southeastern SEU 7-3 , 4-3
48
Winner Ave Maria (FL) AVE 7-4 , 5-2
Southeastern SEU
7-3 , 4-3
45
Final
48
Ave Maria (FL) AVE
7-4 , 5-2
Winner
Score By Quarters
Team 1st 2nd 3rd 4th OT F
SEU Southeastern 0 14 14 17 0 45
AVE Ave Maria (FL) 10 14 7 14 3 48

Game Recap: Football |

Football Wins Wild Regular Season Finale

AVE MARIA, Fla. — Ave Maria has been playing football since 2011. In those 16 seasons, there have been a lot of memorable moments. From the eight-win season in 2013, to the three ranked wins in 2018 that led to a Sun Division Championship, and the 26-point comeback against Florida Memorial in 2025, the Ave Maria Football team has given Gyrene Nation many Saturdays to look back fondly over.

The Gyrenes added one more game to that memorable list Saturday night, as they put together arguably the most entertaining game in program history. Going into overtime for just the third time ever, the Ave Maria Gyrenes defeated the Southeastern Fire 48-45 in the regular season finale.

A combined 17 points were scored between the two squads in the final two minutes of regulation to send the game to the extra period. It was in the fifth frame when Southeastern missed a 24-yard field to keep the game tied and the Gyrenes knocked a kick through to win the game.

Going back all the way to start of the game, Ave Maria took the lead on their second drive and held onto it for 54 minutes and 12 seconds. The drive was set up by a stellar defensive play on the Fire's first possession of the night. On just the second play from scrimmage for the Fire, SEU's quarterback Zach Pleuss's pass was deflected and intercepted at the line of scrimmage by Gregory Thomas III. It was the first career interception for the sophomore defensive end and set the Gyrene offense up at the Fire's 36-yard line.

Three plays later, Ave Maria lit up the scoreboard with a little trickeration from the offense. Wide receiver Oliver Nieman went in motion and received a handoff on what looked to be a run of the mill jet sweep. However, Nieman hit the brakes and lofted a pass to Logan Howard who was all alone on the sideline. Howard ran the ball into the end zone for the 27-yard pass play the resulted in six points.

Nieman, a sophomore from Clarkston, Michigan, attempted a few of passes at his alma mater of Everest Collegiate HS, but all fell incomplete, making his strike to Howard his first ever completion. Howard, who started the year at wide receiver, caught his second touchdown of the year, and first since Fort Lauderdale.

On the following drive, the Gyrene defense got another stop, this time holding the Fire on fourth down for a turnover on downs. This set up the offense in plus territory, and they were able to get a field goal out of it as Jeremy Burch nailed a 48-yard kick.

The field goal proved to be pivotal for most of the game as both offenses found their groove in the second quarter. Southeastern scored five touchdowns between the second and the middle of the fourth quarter but always remained three points behind the Gyrenes thanks to the kick.

The two defenses traded interceptions on the next two drives. Senior Johnny Nedwick picked his second interception of the season and the fourth of his career. Ave Maria was looking at taking a three-score lead, but the Fire secured their only turnover of the night with an interception to return the favor. The Fire scored on the following drive at the start of the second quarter to make it 10-7.

The second quarter marked the start of the shootout Saturday turned out to be. The two teams combined for eight touchdowns across 11 drives between second, third and opening minutes of the fourth quarter. It followed a pattern of Southeastern scoring to make it a three-score game, followed by an immediate touchdown from the Gyrenes to regain a 10-point advantage.

Ave Maria's second touchdown of the night came from the inverse of the first touchdown. This time, Howard found Nieman for a 32-yard strike that put Ave Maria up 17-7.

After a Southeastern touchdown, the Gyrenes got back on the board with Howard finding Athanasius Niewald for nine-yard touchdown pass, giving AMU a 24-14 lead.

The Gyrene defense got another turnover on downs on the following Southeastern drive, stopping the scoring for a moment. AMU's offense stalled as well and punted the ball with 20 seconds left in the first half. Southeastern ran a couple of plays before two teams went into halftime with Ave Maria up by 10.

Southeastern got the ball to start second half and put together the longest drive of the night, spanning 14 plays and 7:06 of game time. The drive was successful, resulting in a touchdown and bringing SEU back within three.

Ave Maria immediately put the lead back at 10, as they needed just 50 seconds to march down the field and score their fourth touchdown of the night. It was the usual suspects as Howard connected with Neiman again for a 64-yard touchdown to give AMU a 31-21 lead.

Both teams traded strategies on the next two drives as Southeastern scored with a quick possession and Ave Maria scored on a methodical drive.

The Fire needed just over a minute to score their fourth touchdown of the night and get back within three of Ave Maria. The Gyrenes then slowed down the pace, putting together a 6:58 drive that lasted 15 plays, and ended with Howard finding Soltau in the back of the endzone for a three-yard strike. The play initially called incomplete, but head coach Joe Patterson threw the red challenge flag, and after a lengthy review, the call was overturned to a touchdown. AMU's scoring drive was the end of the scoring streak for both teams bled into the fourth quarter.

"I had a good line of sight on the play, and [Soltau]'s made that play in practice over and over, he's got really good body control. He is just playing really good ball, so I trusted my eyes and I trusted his feet," said Coach Patterson about the challenge after the game.

Both defenses got a stop their next times out and the margin remained at 10 points with a little over seven minutes left to play. Southeastern needed less than two minutes to score their fifth touchdown of the game and bring the deficit back to three.

The Gyrenes tried to run out the clock on their next drive, but a stop on fourth down gave the ball over to the Fire with just a little over two minutes left on the clock. Southeastern made the most of it, traveling 54 yards in two plays and taking their first lead of the game with 1:54 left to play.

Trailing for the first time, Ave Maria started to feel the pressure of the moment but regained their composure when they needed to most. The Gyrenes marched 75 yards in 76 seconds, and Howard found Neiman for a third and final time to put Ave Maria back in front 45-42.

The Gyrenes left 38 seconds on the clock, and even that proved to be too much time. Southeastern secured a big pass play on their first play of the drive, setting up first and goal at the 10-yard line for the Fire. SEU was 10 yards away from victory, but the Gyrene defense held strong for three straight plays, holding the Fire to a 27-yard field goal that tied the game at 45.

The Gyrenes took a knee on the last play of regulation to send the game into overtime. It is just the third ever game to go to OT in AMU program history and the first time since 2019.

Southeastern started on offense in the extra frame and quickly got inside the 10-yard line. Just like in the fourth quarter though, the Gyrene defense held strong and forced a kick from the Fire inside the 10-yard line. However, Southeastern's kicker Joel McGrath missed the chip shot from 24 yard wide left, keeping the game tied at 45. The senior kicker was 20-for-21 on kicks between 20 and 29 yards leading up to the attempt and hadn't missed a kick from that distance since October 26, 2024.

Ave Maria just needed a field goal to win the game. The offense was thinking six for most of their time out there, getting the ball down to the 1-yard line. Though they could not punch the ball in, Burch got the job down with an 18-yard field goal to win the game 48-45.

At a combined 93 points, it is the highest scoring game in program history.

"The team played inspired ball today as they have throughout conference play," said coach Patterson following the game. "We talked all week about the importance of finishing and tonight was a game that came down to the finish."

Individually, Howard led the team offensively tying a program record of five touchdown pass. His one receiving touchdown as well gave him six touchdowns on the night, becoming just the second ever Gyrene to be in on six scores in a single game. He ties Clayton Uecker, who threw for five and rushed for one touchdown against Point in 2014. Howard finishes his Ave Maria career with 18 touchdowns, giving him the fourth-most in program history.

Howard, Neiman and fellow senior quarterback Ty Keller threw for 281 yards on 20 completions. Five Gyrenes tied with three receptions, led by Neiman with 125 yards and three touchdowns. His three touchdowns ties the program record, matching Karim Bryant's three-touchdown game in 2013 against Florida Tech.

On the ground, Howard was the leading rusher with 92 yards on 21 carries.

Defensively, senior Adam Denver led the team with nine total tackles. Elijah Douge led the team with two tackles for a loss. Aiden Holmes logged the only sack of the night for the defense. Through the air, Thomas III and Nedwick logged the two interceptions. The Gyrenes finish the year with 15 interceptions, matching their 2025 total and the tying for the most interceptions in a season under coach Patterson. Combined with nine fumble recoveries, the Gyrenes totaled 24 takeaways, which is also the most under Coach Patterson.

With the win, Ave Maria finishes the season 7-4 overall and 5-2 in conference play. The Gyrenes finish tied for second in the standings with the Keiser Seahawks. It is the most wins in a single season since 2013.

"This was the sort of the epitome of a team win. The defense carried us for much of the season, and they stood firm in overtime. The offense has really come one strong late in the season, and they're just playing with great execution and great confidence," said Patterson.

With that storybook ending, the 2026 season comes to a close for the Gyrenes. Ave Maria now patiently waits for 2027, knowing that there are more bright spots to come.
Print Friendly Version